A pick's value = how late it went vs how it produced. Returns & waiver moves are 2019+; waiver/trade moves reconstructed from weekly rosters (ESPN exposes no transaction log).
Biggest steals
Late-round gold1Drake MayeDevion · 2025 · Rd 16 Pk 1 · 399.2 pts+148
2Dak PrescottFrost · 2025 · Rd 14 Pk 8 · 391.1 pts+134
3Dak PrescottMeek · 2019 · Rd 14 Pk 9 · 360.2 pts+134
4Justin HerbertManny · 2025 · Rd 15 Pk 2 · 351.9 pts+130
5Kyler MurrayChengy · 2019 · Rd 14 Pk 7 · 308.3 pts+129
6Dak PrescottBryan · 2023 · Rd 14 Pk 3 · 348.1 pts+126
7Tom BradyManny · 2021 · Rd 13 Pk 5 · 429.7 pts+123
8Brock PurdyBryan · 2024 · Rd 14 Pk 10 · 276.7 pts+121
9Brock PurdyDez · 2025 · Rd 16 Pk 3 · 218.2 pts+117
10Josh AllenCrock · 2020 · Rd 12 Pk 10 · 444.8 pts+117
11Courtland SuttonTyler · 2019 · Rd 16 Pk 5 · 215.2 pts+110
12Kyle Pitts Sr.Marcus · 2025 · Rd 16 Pk 5 · 201.0 pts+110
1Devion · 2025 · Rd 16 Pk 1 · 399.2 pts
+1482Frost · 2025 · Rd 14 Pk 8 · 391.1 pts
+1343Meek · 2019 · Rd 14 Pk 9 · 360.2 pts
+1344Manny · 2025 · Rd 15 Pk 2 · 351.9 pts
+1305Chengy · 2019 · Rd 14 Pk 7 · 308.3 pts
+1296Bryan · 2023 · Rd 14 Pk 3 · 348.1 pts
+1267Manny · 2021 · Rd 13 Pk 5 · 429.7 pts
+1238Bryan · 2024 · Rd 14 Pk 10 · 276.7 pts
+1219Dez · 2025 · Rd 16 Pk 3 · 218.2 pts
+11710Crock · 2020 · Rd 12 Pk 10 · 444.8 pts
+11711Tyler · 2019 · Rd 16 Pk 5 · 215.2 pts
+11012Marcus · 2025 · Rd 16 Pk 5 · 201.0 pts
+110Biggest busts
Reach of the year1Saquon BarkleyCrock · 2020 · Rd 1 Pk 2 · 15.4 pts-145
2Christian McCaffreyCrock · 2024 · Rd 1 Pk 3 · 47.8 pts-132
3Antonio BrownFrance · 2019 · Rd 2 Pk 3 · 16.1 pts-127
4Nick ChubbBryan · 2023 · Rd 2 Pk 3 · 25.1 pts-124
5J.K. DobbinsCrock · 2021 · Rd 4 Pk 5 · 0.0 pts-122
6Malik NabersDez · 2025 · Rd 1 Pk 8 · 59.1 pts-119
7Javonte WilliamsDez · 2022 · Rd 3 Pk 2 · 42.0 pts-116
8Isiah PachecoChengy · 2024 · Rd 2 Pk 6 · 56.9 pts-113
9Courtland SuttonChengy · 2020 · Rd 4 Pk 7 · 9.6 pts-112
10Tyreek HillManny · 2025 · Rd 3 Pk 2 · 55.5 pts-110
11Elijah MitchellChengy · 2022 · Rd 4 Pk 6 · 26.1 pts-109
12Zamir WhiteDevion · 2024 · Rd 5 Pk 2 · 21.5 pts-105
1Crock · 2020 · Rd 1 Pk 2 · 15.4 pts
-1452Crock · 2024 · Rd 1 Pk 3 · 47.8 pts
-1323France · 2019 · Rd 2 Pk 3 · 16.1 pts
-1274Bryan · 2023 · Rd 2 Pk 3 · 25.1 pts
-1245Crock · 2021 · Rd 4 Pk 5 · 0.0 pts
-1226Dez · 2025 · Rd 1 Pk 8 · 59.1 pts
-1197Dez · 2022 · Rd 3 Pk 2 · 42.0 pts
-1168Chengy · 2024 · Rd 2 Pk 6 · 56.9 pts
-1139Chengy · 2020 · Rd 4 Pk 7 · 9.6 pts
-11210Manny · 2025 · Rd 3 Pk 2 · 55.5 pts
-11011Chengy · 2022 · Rd 4 Pk 6 · 26.1 pts
-10912Devion · 2024 · Rd 5 Pk 2 · 21.5 pts
-105Best waiver pickups
Undrafted · 2019+1Lamar JacksonCrock · 2019492.7
2Baker MayfieldDevion · 2024402.5
3Brock PurdyManny · 2023337.1
4Ben RoethlisbergerBryan · 2020333.2
5Jameis WinstonTyler · 2019328.5
6Ryan TannehillDevion · 2020321.8
7Josh AllenFrost · 2019310.4
8Caleb WilliamsFrost · 2025307.4
9Matthew StaffordMeek · 2025295.0
10Kirk CousinsDevion · 2021281.1
11Puka NacuaDevion · 2023274.5
12Geno SmithDonte · 2022262.4
1Crock · 2019
492.72Devion · 2024
402.53Manny · 2023
337.14Bryan · 2020
333.25Tyler · 2019
328.56Devion · 2020
321.87Frost · 2019
310.48Frost · 2025
307.49Meek · 2025
295.010Devion · 2021
281.111Devion · 2023
274.512Donte · 2022
262.4Players nobody drafted that year, ranked by points scored for whoever grabbed them.
Worst drops
The ones that got away · est.1Jared Goffdropped by Devion · 2024230.5
2Jared Goffdropped by Chengy · 2025226.1
3Chase Browndropped by Bryan · 2024216.5
4Justin Jeffersondropped by Devion · 2020214.4
5Jared Goffdropped by Beav · 2025200.0
6Brock Purdydropped by Dez · 2025197.4
7Tua Tagovailoadropped by Donte · 2022197.4
8Darnell Mooneydropped by Meek · 2024194.7
9Jordan Lovedropped by Meek · 2025193.9
10Kenneth Walker IIIdropped by Beav · 2022193.1
11RJ Harveydropped by Beav · 2025191.0
12Jared Goffdropped by Marcus · 2025187.6
1dropped by Devion · 2024
230.52dropped by Chengy · 2025
226.13dropped by Bryan · 2024
216.54dropped by Devion · 2020
214.45dropped by Beav · 2025
200.06dropped by Dez · 2025
197.47dropped by Donte · 2022
197.48dropped by Meek · 2024
194.79dropped by Meek · 2025
193.910dropped by Beav · 2022
193.111dropped by Beav · 2025
191.012dropped by Marcus · 2025
187.6Points a player scored after being cut to waivers (detected trades excluded). Reconstructed from rosters, so it's an estimate.
Trades that backfired
Should've kept him · est.1Josh AllenDez → Meek · 2021428.5
2Josh AllenDez → Meek · 2023424.5
3Lamar JacksonMeek → Dez · 2023383.7
4Jayden DanielsManny → Meek · 2024332.9
5Dak PrescottFrost → Crawf · 2021285.7
6Tyreek HillMeek → Frost · 2020274.3
7Aaron RodgersMeek → Chengy · 2019274.1
8Kyler MurrayChengy → Frost · 2019266.3
9Stefon DiggsFrost → Manny · 2020259.2
10Derrick HenryBryan → Meek · 2020255.6
11Lamar JacksonMeek → Dez · 2021254.0
12Leonard FournetteDez → Meek · 2021246.7
1Dez → Meek · 2021
428.52Dez → Meek · 2023
424.53Meek → Dez · 2023
383.74Manny → Meek · 2024
332.95Frost → Crawf · 2021
285.76Meek → Frost · 2020
274.37Meek → Chengy · 2019
274.18Chengy → Frost · 2019
266.39Frost → Manny · 2020
259.210Bryan → Meek · 2020
255.611Meek → Dez · 2021
254.012Dez → Meek · 2021
246.7Players shipped in a trade who then piled up points for their new team. A trade is inferred from reciprocal same-week movement.
Draft grades
Cumulative value · 2019+1DT48 picks · +21 avg / pick+1000
2Crawf80 picks · +5 avg / pick+379
3AJ32 picks · +8 avg / pick+245
4Frost112 picks · +2 avg / pick+220
5Beav64 picks · +3 avg / pick+213
6Manny96 picks · +1 avg / pick+120
7Bryan80 picks · 0 avg / pick+36
8Majae32 picks · -1 avg / pick-42
9Tyler16 picks · -3 avg / pick-50
10Marcus16 picks · -5 avg / pick-82
11France16 picks · -5 avg / pick-83
12Devion96 picks · -1 avg / pick-105
13Chengy112 picks · -1 avg / pick-110
14Donte16 picks · -13 avg / pick-204
15Meek112 picks · -3 avg / pick-302
16Crock112 picks · -5 avg / pick-537
17Dez80 picks · -8 avg / pick-602
148 picks · +21 avg / pick
+1000280 picks · +5 avg / pick
+379332 picks · +8 avg / pick
+2454112 picks · +2 avg / pick
+220564 picks · +3 avg / pick
+213696 picks · +1 avg / pick
+120780 picks · 0 avg / pick
+36832 picks · -1 avg / pick
-42916 picks · -3 avg / pick
-501016 picks · -5 avg / pick
-821116 picks · -5 avg / pick
-831296 picks · -1 avg / pick
-10513112 picks · -1 avg / pick
-1101416 picks · -13 avg / pick
-20415112 picks · -3 avg / pick
-30216112 picks · -5 avg / pick
-5371780 picks · -8 avg / pick
-602Draft board
Pick by pick · 2018 · partialPickOwner · PlayerPts / Value
1.01Le'Veon BellDT——
1.02Todd Gurley IIMeek——
1.03David JohnsonFrost——
1.04Ezekiel ElliottFrance——
1.05Alvin KamaraDevion——
1.06Antonio BrownChengy——
1.07Saquon BarkleyTyler——
1.08Leonard FournetteMajae——
1.09Odell Beckham Jr.Meek——
1.10DeAndre HopkinsManny——
2.01Julio JonesFrost——
2.02Keenan AllenDT——
2.03Dalvin CookMajae——
2.04Kareem HuntTyler——
2.05Melvin GordonChengy——
2.06Michael ThomasDevion——
2.07Aaron RodgersFrance——
2.08Davante AdamsManny——
2.09Devonta FreemanCrock——
2.10Christian McCaffreyCrock——
3.01Jordan HowardCrock——
3.02Rob GronkowskiCrock——
3.03Mike EvansManny——
3.04A.J. GreenFrance——
3.05Travis KelceDevion——
3.06Tyreek HillChengy——
3.07LeSean McCoyTyler——
3.08Zach ErtzMajae——
3.09Adam ThielenMeek——
3.10Stefon DiggsFrost——
4.01Alex CollinsManny——
4.02Larry FitzgeraldCrock——
4.03T.Y. HiltonMajae——
4.04Demaryius ThomasTyler——
4.05Joe MixonChengy——
4.06Chris HoganDevion——
4.07Josh GordonFrance——
4.08Amari CooperFrost——
4.09Doug BaldwinDT——
4.10Jarvis LandryCrock——
5.01Jerick McKinnonMeek——
5.02Royce FreemanCrock——
5.03Marshawn LynchManny——
5.04Derrick HenryFrance——
5.05Tom BradyDT——
5.06Cam NewtonCrock——
5.07Allen RobinsonTyler——
5.08Deshaun WatsonMajae——
5.09Golden TateMeek——
5.10Brandin CooksManny——
6.01JuJu Smith-SchusterFrost——
6.02Dion LewisDevion——
6.03Marvin Jones Jr.Majae——
6.04Greg OlsenTyler——
6.05Russell WilsonChengy——
6.06Corey DavisManny——
6.07Kenyan DrakeFrance——
6.08Lamar MillerFrost——
6.09Carson WentzMeek——
6.10Jimmy GrahamChengy——
7.01Robert WoodsChengy——
7.02Delanie WalkerManny——
7.03Duke Johnson Jr.Devion——
7.04Alshon JefferyFrance——
7.05Evan EngramDevion——
7.06Jay AjayiChengy——
7.07Emmanuel SandersTyler——
7.08Sammy WatkinsMajae——
7.09Cooper KuppDevion——
7.10Mark Ingram IIDT——
8.01Julian EdelmanFrost——
8.02Jordan ReedMeek——
8.03Chris ThompsonMajae——
8.04Jaguars D/STTyler——
8.05Kyle RudolphChengy——
8.06Kirk CousinsDevion——
8.07Michael CrabtreeFrance——
8.08Rex BurkheadCrock——
8.09Tevin ColemanFrost——
8.10Jack DoyleDT——
9.01Randall CobbDT——
9.02Jamaal WilliamsManny——
9.03Will Fuller VDevion——
9.04Isaiah CrowellFrance——
9.05James WhiteDevion——
9.06Eagles D/STChengy——
9.07Devin FunchessTyler——
9.08Tarik CohenMajae——
9.09Robby AndersonMeek——
9.10Ben RoethlisbergerDT——
10.01David NjokuManny——
10.02Marquise GoodwinDT——
10.03Jordy NelsonMajae——
10.04Kerryon JohnsonTyler——
10.05Pierre GarconChengy——
10.06Rams D/STManny——
10.07Carlos HydeFrance——
10.08Andrew LuckFrost——
10.09Vikings D/STMeek——
10.10Drew BreesDT——
11.01Rashaad PennyCrock——
11.02Chris CarsonDT——
11.03Trey BurtonFrost——
11.04Jamison CrowderFrance——
11.05Sterling ShepardDT——
11.06Adrian PetersonChengy——
11.07Ronald JonesTyler——
11.08Kelvin BenjaminMajae——
11.09Philip RiversMeek——
11.10Matthew StaffordManny——
12.01Peyton BarberDT——
12.02Mike WilliamsCrock——
12.03Josh DoctsonMajae——
12.04Kenny StillsTyler——
12.05DJ MooreCrock——
12.06Marlon MackDevion——
12.07DeVante ParkerFrance——
12.08Tyler LockettCrock——
12.09Bilal PowellFrost——
12.10Nelson AgholorCrock——
13.01Jared GoffFrost——
13.02Aaron JonesManny——
13.03Theo RiddickFrost——
13.04Sony MichelFrance——
13.05Greg ZuerleinDevion——
13.06Patrick MahomesChengy——
13.07Matt RyanTyler——
13.08Justin TuckerMajae——
13.09Marqise LeeMeek——
13.10Stephen GostkowskiManny——
14.01Ty MontgomeryManny——
14.02Latavius MurrayMeek——
14.03Ravens D/STMajae——
14.04Jimmy GaroppoloTyler——
14.05Mohamed SanuChengy——
14.06Patriots D/STDevion——
14.07Charles ClayFrance——
14.08Broncos D/STFrost——
14.09Austin HooperMeek——
14.10Wil LutzFrost——
15.01Panthers D/STCrock——
15.02Chargers D/STDT——
15.03Geronimo AllisonFrost——
15.04Texans D/STFrance——
15.05Kenny GolladayDevion——
15.06Chris BoswellChengy——
15.07Cameron BrateTyler——
15.08Javorius AllenMajae——
15.09Matt PraterMeek——
15.10Marcus MariotaManny——
16.01Adam VinatieriCrock——
16.02Dez BryantMeek——
16.03Giovani BernardMajae——
16.04Matt BryantTyler——
16.05Saints D/STChengy——
16.06Mitchell TrubiskyDevion——
16.07Robbie GouldFrance——
16.08Devontae BookerMeek——
16.09Benjamin WatsonDT——
16.10Harrison ButkerDT——
1.01DT
—1.02Meek
—1.03Frost
—1.04France
—1.05Devion
—1.06Chengy
—1.07Tyler
—1.08Majae
—1.09Meek
—1.10Manny
—2.01Frost
—2.02DT
—2.03Majae
—2.04Tyler
—2.05Chengy
—2.06Devion
—2.07France
—2.08Manny
—2.09Crock
—2.10Crock
—3.01Crock
—3.02Crock
—3.03Manny
—3.04France
—3.05Devion
—3.06Chengy
—3.07Tyler
—3.08Majae
—3.09Meek
—3.10Frost
—4.01Manny
—4.02Crock
—4.03Majae
—4.04Tyler
—4.05Chengy
—4.06Devion
—4.07France
—4.08Frost
—4.09DT
—4.10Crock
—5.01Meek
—5.02Crock
—5.03Manny
—5.04France
—5.05DT
—5.06Crock
—5.07Tyler
—5.08Majae
—5.09Meek
—5.10Manny
—6.01Frost
—6.02Devion
—6.03Majae
—6.04Tyler
—6.05Chengy
—6.06Manny
—6.07France
—6.08Frost
—6.09Meek
—6.10Chengy
—7.01Chengy
—7.02Manny
—7.03Devion
—7.04France
—7.05Devion
—7.06Chengy
—7.07Tyler
—7.08Majae
—7.09Devion
—7.10DT
—8.01Frost
—8.02Meek
—8.03Majae
—8.04Tyler
—8.05Chengy
—8.06Devion
—8.07France
—8.08Crock
—8.09Frost
—8.10DT
—9.01DT
—9.02Manny
—9.03Devion
—9.04France
—9.05Devion
—9.06Chengy
—9.07Tyler
—9.08Majae
—9.09Meek
—9.10DT
—10.01Manny
—10.02DT
—10.03Majae
—10.04Tyler
—10.05Chengy
—10.06Manny
—10.07France
—10.08Frost
—10.09Meek
—10.10DT
—11.01Crock
—11.02DT
—11.03Frost
—11.04France
—11.05DT
—11.06Chengy
—11.07Tyler
—11.08Majae
—11.09Meek
—11.10Manny
—12.01DT
—12.02Crock
—12.03Majae
—12.04Tyler
—12.05Crock
—12.06Devion
—12.07France
—12.08Crock
—12.09Frost
—12.10Crock
—13.01Frost
—13.02Manny
—13.03Frost
—13.04France
—13.05Devion
—13.06Chengy
—13.07Tyler
—13.08Majae
—13.09Meek
—13.10Manny
—14.01Manny
—14.02Meek
—14.03Majae
—14.04Tyler
—14.05Chengy
—14.06Devion
—14.07France
—14.08Frost
—14.09Meek
—14.10Frost
—15.01Crock
—15.02DT
—15.03Frost
—15.04France
—15.05Devion
—15.06Chengy
—15.07Tyler
—15.08Majae
—15.09Meek
—15.10Manny
—16.01Crock
—16.02Meek
—16.03Majae
—16.04Tyler
—16.05Chengy
—16.06Devion
—16.07France
—16.08Meek
—16.09DT
—16.10DT
—Player-level scoring starts in 2019, so this draft shows the board only — no returns.